Feb 2010: G Data, Avira, Panda Aug 2010: G Data, TrustPort, McAfee Avast, Feb 2011: G Data, TrustPort! G Data is obviously doing very well. Odd that it’s not the best according to AV-Test. Let’s track the marketplace leaders by their position in the top 20: Symantec: 7,6,12 (medium positions) McAfee: 5,3,10 (close to the top) Trend Micro: 18,13,13 (almost always close to the base) “Underside” in this case means >90% detection; We Are talking about 90% of thousands of latest and the most dangerous virus threats, therefore I suppose it’s good enough anyhow. Virus Bulletin Virus Bulletin is the most advanced website, giving the results that are most extensive and measuring the broadest variety of vendor products. They’ve loads of historical data on product functionality that is antivirus. Let us take their RAP (Reactive and Proactive) evaluation from October 2010 to April 2011. The finest sellers Kaspersky, Trustport, Coranti, Avira, G Data.
How are the leaders doing? Symantec: ~90%-80% (definitely top quadrant) McAfee: ~ 75%-75% (average results) Trend Micro continues to be boycotting this test for 3 years (hmm) If it is tested by independent sources so what can be said about antivirus protection? – The results do not match. Fully different vendors arrive at the top and fall to the bottom without any indication of why – Top sales sellers are average or below average in their own protection level and the best spots are awarded to small businesses – The same vendor can reveal a great result on exactly the same evaluation in 2010 and drop down a year later – Websites of the antivirus vendors are full of certifications got from one of these three labs. Each of the 52 vendors has at least one. I am not sure how buyoemsoftware.biz to compare them based on this particular information. Power of the fourth estate There are lots of computer magazines. And they’re issued every month.
Marketing research says the guidance from computer news sources is among the most important factors in the decision making of antivirus product customers. Let’s look at some comparison charts from different sources (original version of this post on Antivirus Direct features links to the posts) Dennis Technology Labs, “PC Total Protection Packages 2011,” February 2011 Best Options: Symantec, Trend Micro, Webroot PassMark Applications, “Consumer Security Products Operation Benchmarks (Variation 3 Feb. 2011),” February 2011. Best Choises: Symantec, ESET, G Data ConsumerSearch Best Options: Symantec, avast!, Sophos TopTenReviews Best Options: BitDefender, Kaspersky, Webroot Antiviruscompare Greatest Choises: ESET, Symantec, Mcafee PCMab Greatest Options: K7, Symantec, Kaspersky CNet Finest Alternatives: Kaspersky, Mcafee, TrendMicro I could continue posting dozens of screenshots, but I believe I Have made my point. Decide any of the 52 sellers and there will be an IT magazine that’ll rate it number 1.